To liberate Indians from self-imposed colonial shackles.
A few weeks ago I was giving a talk at a college in Gurgaon in Haryana, India, when a young student raised her hand. Urvashi was visibly nervous; I could see that it took a lot of courage for her to speak up in Hindi. “Where can I take computer classes in Hindi-medium?” she asked. I had no proper answer, but I had come across similar questions in rural settings, though not in the heart of the neo-urban metropolis of Gurgaon. On the one hand, we credit India’s success in software to our knowledge of English, on the other we fret about India’s relatively low level of Internet penetration relative to China. Looking beyond English in India provides opportunities to social and business entrepreneurs alike. But first we must take off our English tinted glasses.
A recent Supreme Court judgment on the Right to Education Act suggested that we are falling behind China since “children in China are learning English”. This is a fallacy—the Chinese may be learning English but they are not switching their medium to English—all higher education takes place in Chinese. The obsession with English-medium education, particularly for technical and higher studies, is keeping millions of Indian children behind. The top business and professional schools in India remain English-based—their entrance exams are not only in English but specifically test English-language skills. A child in China, or for that matter, Japan or South Korea, does not have to deal with debilitating switch in medium to go to engineering, medical or business school. Yet, this has not prevented these countries from creating some of the largest multinationals in the world—all on the basis of higher education in local languages of higher education in local languages. As demand for education in the rural and semi- urban markets picks up, it is worth remembering that only four of the richest 20 economies in the world, by highest per-capita income, are English-based. Universal education, not English-medium, is what gives China the advantage over India. Over 300 million people use the Internet in China—in Mandarin.
It is also a fallacy that our software success is built on knowledge of English. Israel’s population is half of Delhi’s, yet its software exports rival our own. It is true that many people in Israel do know English, though not many know it well. When I was a manager for Microsoft visiting my team in Haifa, I was surprised to find that the medium of communication—written and oral—within the Microsoft Israel office was Hebrew. In this office of a major multinational, internal communications were all in Hebrew, as is Technion, Israel’s top engineering college. A culture that values knowledge—similar to that in India—not the medium of education, has driven Israel to create some of the most innovative software companies in the world.
However, every mismatched supply-demand situation creates an opportunity for entrepreneurs. Here are some obvious ones. The first is there is a market for technical education in Indian languages that is under-served. Some weeks ago someone from Tamil Nadu sent me a proposal for creating technical education institutes. “Make sure you offer Tamil-medium,” I suggested. While initially these classes may need to have lower fees, over time there is a much larger base of students to tap. It is up to us to respond to that opportunity once we start looking beyond English.
The second opportunity is in hiring. When I was working at Microsoft, Redmond, we flew software engineers from as far away as Russia for interviews. Some of these people did not speak a word of English—I interviewed them through interpreters and they were some of the best hires I made.
Yet, in India, we may overlook talent if we insist on conducting interviews for technical candidates only in English, rather than the language they would be most comfortable speaking. The goal—to evaluate them based on their technical proficiency, rather than their knowledge of English.
The third opportunity is to spread back office operations from the large cities to smaller towns and semi-rural settings, affording lower cost and access to a broader talent base. Again, flexibility and openness about language use will allow this opportunity to be tapped. If specific language skills are required, these can be imparted as part of on-the-job. Why restrict ourselves to the English opportunity alone? BPO and call centres from France to Japan beckon. The opportunity to get a complete education in our mother tongues, combined with the ability to learn any language as a skill as needed, will bring greater, more-broad based economic opportunities and liberate us from self-imposed colonial shackles of English. This will help to propel us towards a developed economy—and lift all entrepreneur boats—in which every Urvashi can participate.
© Sankrant Sanu., all rights reserved.
12 thoughts on “Opportunities Beyond English”
I really like the body and idea behind the article. Very practical, and moving day by day to be a necessary element for well settled businesses and start-ups.
Thanks for sharing your ideas.
main iss baat se poori tarah sehmat hoon aur main bhi yahi chahti hoon ki hamara padhai ka madhyam hindi ho, jo ki hamari rashtriya bhasha hai, na ke koi videsh ki bhassha. jai hind
to ye baat apko hindi m likhni chahiye………
Hindi mein isliye nahin likhi kyunki Angrezi valon ko samjhana zyada zaroori hai. :0
really a very good read sir.. an eye-opener for the people obsessed with english.. very interesting facts and instances to support that english is not the only medium of progress.. a large fraction of our population speaks hindi specially people from rural areas of northern states.. so the kids when they go for higher technical education have to struggle a lot just because of the compulsion of english.. i think they would be more productive and efficient if education is provided to them in the language they are most comfortable with.
Namaste Sir.. Very good article I have ever read. Thanks a lot for these type of posts. Sir, I would like to share this to my friends… so waiting for your permission….
Language should be facilitator and not a barrier to one’s success, I don’t know how much have we benefitted from knowing english but one thing is sure that we are losing some best talent because of our obsession with english and if we really look deep the problem is much wider and deeper, We were anyways divided by caste,colour, religion, but now we are divided as “English Speaking” and “Non English Speaking” . From education to job and even for marriage “English” as become a must.
There is nothing wrong with “English”, what needs attention is our “obsession” with “Englsh”. I wish we can create some obsession for Sanskrit :).
इस लेख को छपे ६ साल होने जा रहें हैं पर अभी तक देशी भाषाओँ में अवसरों की कोई वृद्धि दिखाई नहीं देती। लगता है जबतक हम जागेंगे अंग्रेजी का साम्राज्य इतना अधिक बढ़ जायेगा कि देशी भाषाएँ उसकी गुलाम हो जेयेंगी।
The idea is great, but the practicality of rolling out curriculum based of one vernacular is very difficult in the Indian Context. South Indians are at odds with Hindi and see it as being enforced. There is no broad acceptance. The author himself notes that a technical institute wanted curriculum in Tamil. These biases have to be bridged and I do see a strong argument for a language of consensus other than English. Till we arrive at that happy medium, I think English is going to linger on.
मेरा मानना है कि आज के समय में हमें – हम सबको – अंग्रेजी इसलिए किसी की कॉपी करने के लिए नहीं, बल्कि औरों का नेतृत्व करने के लिए सीखना चाहिए – अपनी मातृभाषा का पूरा सम्मान करते हुए – और यह संभव है – मैंने इसके लिए एक ‘ओर्गानिक सिस्टम ‘ तैयार किया है । कल्पना कीजिये यदि हमारे ही आर्ट ऑफ़ लिविंग में इंग्लिश बोलने वाले टीचर्स नहीं होते तो क्या हम 120+ देशों तक पहुँच पाते ? अंग्रेज़ी को हम एक औजार की तरह देखें, न कि एक भाषा की तरह |
World leader banane ke liye english jaroori nahi hai. jab pahale bhi ham lead karate the duniya me tab hamane english nahi padhi thi . Ha aur ek cheez “Vishwaguru” ya world leader banane ke liye knowledge important hai, na ki english language/medium.
– your friend
Sir, I red your article published in DNA dated 15th November, 2019 on the recent decision of the GoAP of converting all the Telugu medium schools to English medium and then came across your blog. Your view to think beyond English is of really worth. This ‘English Must’ mentality is really taking us towards the cultural impoverishment. The another aspect of this is reduction in job opportunities. There are very less job opportunities available related to local languages as against English.